China Media Research, Volume 6 No. 1,
January 2010
Yoshitaka Miike
An Anatomy of Eurocentrism in Communication Scholarship: The
Role of Asiacentricity in De-Westernizing Theory and
Research
This article problematizes the Eurocentric structure of
communicative knowledge and advocates the legitimacy of
Asiacentricity in Asian communication studies. The first
section of the article re-articulates the nature and
intersection of humanity, cultural particularities, and
communication. The second section then addresses
Eurocentrism as ideologies of totalization and
trivialization. The third section clarifies the
metatheoretical notion of Asiacentricity and argues for its
intellectual necessity. The present article finally
envisions five ways in which Asiacentricity de-Westernizes
communication scholarship. Asiacentricity (1) generates
theoretical knowledge that corresponds to Asian
communication discourse, (2) focuses on the multiplicity and
complexity of Asian communicative experience, (3)
reflexively constitutes and critically transforms Asian
communication discourse, (4) theorizes how universal aspects
of humanity are expressed and understood in Asian cultural
particularities, and (5) critiques Eurocentric biases in
theory and research and helps Asian researchers overcome
academic dependency.
Xiaodong Dai
Intersubjectivity and Interculturality: A Conceptual Link
Intersubjectivity reflects the condition of all human
existence and constitutes the basis of social communication.
Interculturality opens up new social space and constitutes
the largest and most productive platform for intercultural
dialogue. This paper attempts to define intersubjectivity
and interculturality, interpret their implications and
analyze how they interact with each other. Intersubjectivity
refers to the interpersonal connection between individuals
who are attuned to one another and construct social
relations. The polysemic nature of intersubjectivity
suggests that it not only embodies mutuality and consensuses
but also disagreements and tensions. In like manner,
interculturality refers to the complex connection between
cultures whose members negotiate to reach agreements and
achieve reciprocal interactions. It implies commonalities
and similarities as well as differences, contrasts and
conflicts. Intersubjectivity and interculturality share a
similar structure, but have different operational
mechanisms. The key difference lies in their frames of
reference. With more exposure to other culture/cultures,
communicators can broaden their horizons, reduce cultural
distance and further transform intersubjectivity into
interculturality. In establishing interculturality, they
need to be open to other cultures and transcend monocultural
ways of thinking.
Bingqi Feng and Han Li
In Search of a Western Counterpart of Ch'i: Eastern and
Western Cognitive Frames in Interpreting Relevant Ch'i Terms
This study uses multidimensional scaling (MDS) to explore
how Chinese and North American respondents differ in their
perception of leadership spirit, or Ch'i, a concept that
refers to energy flow, vital force, spirit, or dignity.
Results show that three dimensions (Amenable Charisma,
Magnetic Self-Assuredness, and Engaged Obstinacy) underlie
perceptions of leadership Ch'i by the Chinese subjects, as
contrasted with those underlying North American subjects
(Respectful Amiability, Zealous Inflexibility, and Tentative
Charisma). The differences in the dimensions reveal the
diverse cognitive frames of Chinese and North Americans as
they try to understand leadership spirit. Cross-cultural
understanding between Eastern and Western thinking patterns,
particularly as they relate to leadership qualities, is also
discussed.
Ming-Yi Wu, Ph.D.
Gender and Cultural Influences on Expected Leadership Styles
in the Taiwanese Public Relations Field: Transformational
and Transactional Leadership Styles
In order to bring additional insight into transformational
leadership in the international context, this study surveyed
104 public relations practitioners in Taiwan. The results
suggest that the Taiwanese participants prefer both
transformational and transactional leadership styles.
Comparing male and female participants?answers, the results
indicate that female public relations practitioners have
higher scores on both transformational and transactional
leadership styles. Cultural influences on the
operationalization of transformational leadership are
identified by the results of factor analysis.
Michael B. Hinner
Stereotyping and the Country-of-Origin Effect
Stereotyping and the country-of-origin effect share many
characteristics. People in general have a need to reduce the
world抯 complexity to a manageable level. This is often
accomplished through simplification. Thus, people tend to
reduce the complexity of other cultures to a few
characteristics that are then transferred to individuals
from that culture as well. This simplification is called
stereotyping. Stereotypes can be positive or negative. In
order to understand the formation of stereotypes better and
to provide insights into how stereotypes might be overcome,
the perceptual process can be helpful. In the world of
business, international marketing is aware of a similar
phenomenon when it comes to the associations and attributes
consumers have of products from specific countries. These
attributes can be either positive or negative. While new
products can benefit from positive associations, overcoming
negative attributes can be very difficult. That is why
methods are described which could be helpful in overcoming a
negative country-of-origin effects in marketing.
Morris A. Shapero
The Evolving Mindset of the Chinese Manager
To work effectively with Chinese, Western managers need to
develop greater understanding of Chinese culture and values.
Twenty-five Eckerd College students examined earlier field
research of Hendrick Serrie on Chinese culture and its six
principles (1999). Each group was assigned one principle and
formulated questions and topics that formed the basis of
discussions with managers in China. Upon completing the
project, students completed papers on the assigned
principle, either supporting or challenging it. Eckerd
students found many principles from the research are still
relevant, although certain principles are not as relevant
because of changing values, especially among younger,
well-educated workers.
Cooper S. Wakefield
Nike's Shanghai Advertising Dialectic: A Case Study
This paper gives a description and analysis of two recent
Nike advertising campaigns in Shanghai, China. Located in
conjoined visual space, the two ads form a dialectic that
increases the effectiveness of both ads. The first and
larger in scope of the two campaigns depicts NBA basketball
stars striking gangster-rap style poses (dominating eye
gaze, cocked head positions, frowns, challenging eyebrows,
and generally imposing and intimidating body language) and
employs a non-traditional ad slogan and style. A pilot study
of responses was conducted among university students in
order to gauge responses of locals to this set of ads.
The other ad, located across a major street in a more
confined yet also more prominent space, features Chinese
athletes in a conventionally styled Nike ad. The two
advertisements, which seem to be in opposition, can be seen
as working in tandem.
This paper analyzes the layers of meaning embedded in the
advertisements and their locations in physical space. I
discuss the nonverbal gestures, composition of the
advertisements themselves, and the geosemiotics of the
overall visual space. I rely on the work of Robert Goldman
and Stephen Papson to decode the purpose of these
advertisements, as well as to analyze the reactions to them.
These advertisements provide insight into cultural identity
in Shanghai as perceived by one of the world's most
prominent media producers. Like Nike's US strategy, which
targets different groups with different types of
advertisements, these advertisements clearly appeal to
different types of Shanghai people. This paper not only
explores the two advertisements themselves, but also the
dissimilar cultural identities that the two contrasting
advertisements may reflect and appeal to.
Charu Lata Singh, VIPS
New Media and Cultural Identity
This paper explores and examines the interplay of 'New
media' and 'Cultural identity'. New media as the root cause
of the processes of cultural change. The change which mainly
results because of the technological advancements and
innovations in new media. The paper tries to bring out the
hidden nuances which due to these developments gives rise to
a different culture, hence pose threat to the indigenous
cultures, which stand at the crossroads to identify their
own cultural identities amidst the assimilated and
homogenized cultural forces. It focuses on virtual culture.
The paper provides fresh point of views on moral panics and
the commercial and imperial drives as underlying determiners
of the whole phenomena. What it ultimately requires, is the
new regulations framework pertaining to individualized
global cultures in order to maintain their identities amidst
the churning of these cultures in the sea of new media.
Gennadi Gevorgyan
Does Culture Matter? Using Accommodation, Framing, and
Hofstede Theories to Predict Chinese Voters?Perceptions and
Attitudes toward Culturally Oriented Online Political
Advertising
This paper is an empirical undertaking that aims to explore
the role culture plays in online political communication.
With our general question "Does Culture Matter?" we
investigate the persuasive effects of culturally oriented
online political advertisements. In doing so, we lay the
foundation for a framework that can be used to bridge the
cultural gap through making online political information
more appealing to ethnically diverse citizens. The results
of the study reveal that culture has a significant role in
the formation of Chinese American voters?attitudes toward
political messages. In particular, advertisements with
cultural appeals produce more favorable attitudes than those
with neutral or culturally incongruent appeals. This pattern
is especially visible among citizens with strong ethnic
identities.
Tong Yu
Going Above and Beyond: A Multicultural Warrior An Interview
with Dr. Bates Hoffer
Dr. Bates Hoffer is a renowned scholar who has done
extensive research in intercultural communication,
linguistics, and literature. Dr. Hoffer, former IAICS
president and co-founder of ICS, continues to be active in
scholarship, and in professional, university and community
services. In this interview, Dr. Hoffer shares some of his
intercultural experiences and offers valuable insights on
doing social research.
Guozhen Wang and Peng Hwa Ang
The Principal-Agent Problem in Chinese State-owned Media |